Cornell president calls gang rape allegations ‘deeply disturbing’ as reflected on by Rabbi Miriam Levin
When news of sexual violence on campus breaks, my phone always rings. Parents in our Highland Woods congregation call me. Autumn usually brings conversations about dorm rooms, introductory seminars, and sending eighteen-year-olds into the wider world. However, today cold dread pierces those hopes. Cornell University’s president calls recent gang rape allegations “deeply disturbing.” He refers to this as a “defining moment.” Parents hear something far more visceral. They receive a stark reminder that institutions entrusted with our children often struggle to guarantee their fundamental safety and dignity.
Jewish ethical tradition views human dignity, *k’vod habriyot*, as an absolute moral imperative. It is not just a polite social courtesy. Every person is created *b’tzelem Elohim*, in the divine image. Therefore, violence or sexual assault violates another human being. It defaces that image. It treats a sacred soul as mere property. When an assault occurs in a communal setting, we cannot dismiss the failure as an isolated transgression. Instead, it indicts the culture. That culture permitted such brazen dehumanization to take root, fester, and strike.
Accountability for Gang Rape Allegations
In Deuteronomy, the Torah presents a haunting ritual. It is known as the *eglah arufah*, the ceremony of the heifer. When someone was found slain in an open field, and the perpetrator remained unknown, the elders of the nearest city had a duty. They washed their hands over a heifer and declared: “Our hands did not shed this blood, nor did our eyes see it.” The Talmud asks how anyone could suspect righteous communal elders of murder. The sages answer clearly. The elders were not accused of direct violence. Rather, they accounted for their actions. Had they allowed someone to travel through their midst without protection, without care, and without vigilance? In our contemporary world, leadership cannot wash its hands simply by uttering solemn words after catastrophe strikes. True accountability demands more.
Saying that an institution “must do better” admits failure. However, by itself, it is profoundly inadequate. In Jewish law, true repentance, *teshuvah*, requires much more than acknowledging sorrow. It demands a public cessation of the harm. Furthermore, it requires an unsparing investigation of structural complicity. Genuine restitution is also necessary. Most importantly, an unwavering commitment to change conditions must prevent the offense from recurring. A defining moment is not measured by an eloquent recorded video. Instead, it is measured by the tangible protection offered to the vulnerable. It is measured by the courage to dismantle toxic subcultures, regardless of their powerful defenders.
Sanctuaries of Respect and Safety
In my pastoral work, I serve young adults and families facing trauma. I have learned how easily survivors are re-injured by institutional hesitation. When an administration hesitates to act decisively, the wound deepens. Likewise, when peers close ranks in cowardly silence, the pain intensifies. The Torah commands us, “You shall not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor.” Active bystander intervention, ethical accountability, and mutual responsibility are covenantal obligations. A university fraternity, a dormitory, or a social circle that fosters an atmosphere of predation violates the most elementary covenant of human fellowship. This includes responding to gang rape allegations with clear, decisive action.
Our congregation gathers for study and prayer this week. We hold the survivor in our hearts. Their life has been upended. We also remember every family walking the agonizing road of trauma and recovery. We look honestly at the young people we are raising. Moral education cannot conclude when our children receive their high school diplomas. We must teach them. True strength lies in restraint. Consent is sacred. Standing against cruelty is non-negotiable. Ultimately, our homes, our schools, and our campuses must become sanctuaries of respect, rather than landscapes of peril.
Leave a Reply